Saturday, January 26, 2013

Doubt

Sometimes the doubt gets way too close. I don’t mean doubt about whether God exists or whether I’ll become successful in my career or anything specific. I don’t really know what it is that I doubt, actually. I just know that sometimes it gets too close. If I knew what it was, if I could name what it was that I doubted, it would then be even closer, and unendurable. I can never get close enough to recognize it.

I didn’t really stay up on US news while I
was away. I thought the Te’o story had something to do with parodying Tim Tebow. I’d heard Armstrong was going to have an interview with Oprah, but I didn’t know any of the details until I got back. It seems like the story of our lives, the thin coating we use to name and conceal the scattered rubbish underneath, has become the essence we are most desperate to preserve. And maybe that’s part of what it is that I’m doubting, the story. I want to believe in other people's stories, the story of the cancer survivor who overcame his disease to become a seven time Tour de France champion, for example. And I fully understand why a college student wants to believe in the pretty picture and nice words that come across his computer screen and iphone. I understand why someone would want to believe that life’s tragedies can be remade as heart-warming made-for-cinema victories, would want to confirm those stories, would value the story more than the actual lived experience, would hide the latter with the former. I can understand why someone would lie to preserve his own story, even a false story, see it as a gift to or from others, would do everything he can to make his story true no matter how false, would yield to what’s much bigger than he is.

I’m not sure what the narrative of my life would be. I kinda know what I would like it to be, and I know it isn’t what I'd like it it to be, but as long as it’s not over, my life I mean, as long it keeps going, I can hold onto the story and maybe the story, or the idea that there is a story, keeps me going. Part of the doubt that sometimes gets too close, that I can never name or see too clearly, is the concern that without the story there would not be anything left to motivate me, that, though the story be not only a small part of me but a part of me that in truth isn’t really a part of me, is all or mostly lie, I could not exist without it. And perhaps the only part of me that is real, that is me, is the doubt, the part of me I can’t bear to get too close to because, if I did, it would be the end of me.

2 comments:

Mikayla Loosli said...

"...a part of me that in truth isn’t really a part of me, is all or mostly lie, I could not exist without it. And perhaps the only part of me that is real, that is me, is the doubt, the part of me I can’t bear to get too close to because, if I did, it would be the end of me."
I couldn't have found a better summary of how I've been feeling lately. An unsettling realization (most likely due to extreme over-analysis of every aspect of my life) of how irrelevant my life will most likely accumulate to be, no matter what I choose to do with it. I cling to any slightly interesting story in order to make my life seem relevant. While simultaneously, because I'm aware of the fact that I'm just one of thousands upon thousands, I feel a sense of slight detachment and lack of motivation.
To be relevant and validated, or even "special" is something I think everyone aims to achieve (some may even honest to god believe this about themselves), but in the big scheme of things almost none of us do. I think most of us reject this idea, because of a phenomenon that happens to many Seniors in the last semester of Highschool-- lack of motivation. Why aim to achieve if what you do doesn't really effect anything?
(Very enlightening and thought- provoking blog uncle Shane, I've been reading incessantly for the past few days upon discovery.) :)
-- Katie

shane said...

Thanks for the comments, Katie! Sorry you're experiencing your own doubts. Maybe, though, the sense of detachment and lack of motivation you're feeling isn't necessarily something you need to push away. It's something to work through, certainly, and not something that should become too smothering, but it might also be the most authentic and best part of you. Maybe being irrelevant, if we're judging relevance by mainstream society's standards, is a good thing. I think society imposes a lot of stories on us--tells us that we can't be part of the social world if we don't adopt certain stories and make them part of our self-definition--but maybe that self-definition is really a trap that keeps us from really understanding ourselves. It's tough, though, I know. 18 wasn't a fun age for me, either.

Nice to know that someone is still reading my blog. I look forward to reading more comments!!!